Thursday, November 05, 2026

'Historic First'



The left celebrates this as if it is a victory for a bona fide neglected and glass-ceiling’d minority, in a fashion completely contrary to how they would respond to any other nutty religious intrusion into politics e.g. ‘First Scientologist Senator’. Yay!?

And the worst part is this is not at all like ‘First Buddhist Senator’, because El-Sayed openly aligns with the supremacist, often blatantly racist and completely non-oppressed but rather highly oppressive aspects of Islam in the Middle East. A culture that has systematically hijacked officially-sanctioned oppressed status in a manner that would be obvious to anyone willing to kindle their critical faculties. 


El-Syaed’s hypocrisy on all this is troublesome. Ask him why he has nothing to say about the c50,000 protestor deaths in Iran and he will deflect with some stuff about how it is time for the US to quietly wash its hands of any moral responsibility for Islamic crimes, ‘no more global policeman’ and all that, but when it comes to interfering in the conflict between Israel and Gaza his response becomes far more contorted. 


Sunday, November 01, 2026

'All Inclusive'

The relative success of parties representing Israel’s non-Jewish populations is clearly something for the likes of the Guardian to celebrate, yet it stimulates a certain awkwardness too. ( ‘Apartheid’ and all that.) 

It has been instructive to see how they have presented the story in line with their main dogmas. The principal trick has been to consistently refer to all non-Jews in Israel as’ Palestinians’. 

Having to admit that some of these people might even be ‘Zionists’ would add a whole new layer of awkwardness, but the imposition of of the apparently comforting Pal identity carries with it the suggestion that Israel itself is an imposed colonial superstructure, underneath which there exists a somehow inclusive yet oppressed post-colonial nation waiting to emerge from the flames (nuclear fireball?).  This is counter-factual and dangerously delusional.

Before the state of Israel it was the region’s Jews who identified as ‘Palestinian’. Once Arafat’s movement (heavily influenced by Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood) separated itself from the Arab nationalisms around it in the late sixties and adopted the name themselves, they came up with a flag — and this flag features sections in the colours of green, white and black, representative of the three historical caliphates. As such it is an explicitly expansionist-colonialist emblem hiding in plain sight, far more so than the Israeli flag.

This is one reason it is so readily adopted by Islamists and Islamist-adjacent political movements across Europe and elsewhere. 


Yet it would be fanciful indeed to assume that Israel’s non-Jews would all prefer to live their lives in the society that it portends, as opposed to one which offers them a chance to participate in say, free elections.